http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/hrt-get-107816710ho001ks20110106050005,0,2108204.photo
One of the most recognizable trademarks in today's market, whether you like coffee or not, is Starbucks. The Siren logo has undergone some transformations over the last 40 years and this past week, Starbucks announced a new modification. The Starbucks name in the outer border will be eliminated leaving the Siren image in green and white.
The Starbucks example provides an opportunity for trademark owners to become familiar with the "tacking" doctrine. In the context of both trademark prosecution before the USPTO and infringement actions, a trademark owner may try to claim priority to an earlier version of their mark even though the earlier version will differ in some way from its current form. Under the tacking doctrine, the earlier mark must be the legal equivalent of the current version so that a consumer would consider the older and current version of the mark to be the same. See e.g. Brookfield Comms, Inc. v. West Coast Entertainment Corp., 174 F.3d 1036 (9th Cir.) Both marks must create the same ongoing commercial impression among consumers and the later mark should not differ materially from the earlier version. Id. For more information on tacking, see also 1212.04(b) of the Trademark Manual of Examining Procedure (TMEP) which can be found on the USPTO website.
The chart in the above link illustrates nicely how the Starbucks logo has changed subtly and gradually over time in both color and style. The Starbucks name has been prominently featured on the outer edge of the design with the mermaid in the center since 1971. Even though the Mermaid changed stylistically, the basic structure of the logo remained the same as has the green color (used in the late 1980's). Consumers may be able to easily identify Starbucks coffee based on the green and white mermaid alone in the new mark without the need for "Starbucks Coffee" text in the earlier mark.
Trademark owners looking to modify, if the feel they need to, their marks should take care not to make changes that drastically alter the image. Doing so could result in the creation of a legally new mark and could result in the loss of priority earlier mark's date of first use.
No comments:
Post a Comment