Sunday, February 3, 2013

The Rooster Crows


One aspect of trademark law that has provoked controversy is Section 1052(a) of the Lanham Act’s prohibition on the registration of scandalous or vulgar marks.

Section 1052(a) reads: 
            No trademark by which the goods of the applicant may be distinguished from     the goods of others shall be refused registration on the principal register on account of its nature unless it--
            (a) Consists of or comprises immoral, deceptive, or scandalous matter; or matter which may disparage or falsely suggest a connection with persons, living or dead, institutions, beliefs, or national symbols, or bring them into contempt, or disrepute; or a geographical indication which, when used on or in connection with wines or spirits, identifies a place other than the origin of the goods and is first used on or in connection with wines or spirits by the applicant on or after one year after the date on which the WTO Agreement (as defined in section 2(9) of the Uruguay Round Agreements Act) enters into force with respect to the United States.

Some legal commentators and practitioners have opined that such prohibition runs counter to First Amendment rights enshrined in the U.S. Constitution.  However, the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, (CAFC), has held that the refusal of the USPTO to register a mark does not run afoul of free speech because a mark’s owner is still free to use it to brand their goods and services, (so called common law trademark use).  In re Mavety Media Group Ltd., 33 F.3d 1367 (CAFC 1994).  In previous cases, trademark applicants appealing a 1052(a) refusal have also argued that such refusals violate the Equal Protection Clause based on the USPTO granting other registrations.  The CAFC has noted that registrations on other applications are not binding on the USPTO or Federal Courts.  In re Boulevard Entertainment, Inc., 334 F.3d 1336, 1343 (CAFC 2003).

In re Fox is the Federal Circuit’s most recent decision involving “vulgar marks.”  The applicant sold lollipops in the shape of a rooster.  The lollipops were sold under the mark COCK SUCKER conjoined with the image of a rooster.

The USPTO issued a refusal to register the mark primarily citing the dictionary definition of “cocksucker” (one word) as being one who performs a certain sex-act.  In response, the applicant parsed the mark and argued that each word carried its own “non-vulgar” dictionary definition, namely “’cock as a rooster…and sucker as a lollipop.’”  The applicant also argued that her mark had a space that separated the words in the mark and also that the mark served as a double entendre.  Consumers might recognize the vulgar meaning behind the word.  Yet, the image of the rooster would help them realize the non-vulgar meaning.  The USPTO eventually acknowledged this argument but disagreed with its premise.  The USPTO made a final refusal that “’due to the strong meaning of ‘cocksucker’ in society in general … a substantial composite of the general public will … assign the scandalous meaning to the wording/mark.’”  On appeal to the TTAB, the board noted the possible non-vulgar meaning but sided with the USPTO examining attorney.  The applicant appealed to the CAFC.

The applicant first argued that case law on Section 1052(a) allows for marks having a double entendre and that the literal definition of the mark COCK SUCKER meant “rooster lollipop.”  Judge Dyk rejected this argument noting that the applicant admitted that there was in-fact a vulgar meaning behind the mark.  The Court concluded that the vulgar meaning of the phrase was not “diminished” by the non-vulgar literal meaning (“a poultry-themed product”) advanced by the applicant.

Fox next argued that there is an exception for double entendre marks based on CAFC case law.  The Court held that no such exception existed and focused on the question of whether a “’substantial composite of the general public perceive[d] the mark, in context, to have a vulgar meaning…”  Looking at the statutory language, the Court decided that marks which “include” vulgar or scandalous material are also subject to refusal under 1052(a).  As Fox’s double entendre invoked the vulgar non-literal definition, her mark “comprised” or included vulgarity and therefore the trademark examiner was justified in refusing registration.

Link to the TTAB’s Record including the parties' briefs and the board's opinion affirming the trademark examiner.  HERE

Link to the CAFC’s Opinion HERE