Wednesday, August 31, 2011

"Naked Consent" Agreement Shot Down By TTAB

One way some trademark applicants attempt to overcome a likelihood of confusion refusal from the USPTO is to enter into an agreement with the owner of the previously registered mark that there is no likelihood of confusion.  Guidelines concerning the use of consent agreements can be found at TMEP Section 1207.01(d)(viii).  The agreement should set forth in detail why there would be no likelihood of confusion between the registered mark and the applicant's mark and what steps are being taken to avoid consumer confusion.  Such was not the case in a recent TTAB opinion In re Intuity Medical, Inc. 77416484 (2011 Not Precidential)

The applicant sought to register the standard character mark ONE STEP and ONE-STEP for blood glucose monitoring systems.  The examining attorney refused registration based on likelihood of confusion with three registered marks owned by the same entity.  The examiner, applying the DuPont* factors, first determined that the applicant's mark and the registered marks were for all practical purposes identical in sound, appearance and connotation.  Next, the examiner found that the products associated with the applicant's mark and the registered marks, blood glucose monitoring systems and their components, were related, moved in the same channels of trade and sold to the same class of consumers.

Facing an uphill battle at this point, the applicant's hopes lay with a consent to register agreement which had been made with the owner of the registered marks.  Here is where things went very, very wrong.  The agreement stated that the registrant was giving the applicant permission to:

"use and obtain registration in the United States and internationally of its ONE STEP and ONE-STEP marks in connection with the following goods:  blood glucose monitoring systems including the devices, and parts and accessories thereof in Class 10."

On appeal to the TTAB, the board found that this agreement failed to overcome the likelihood of confusion refusal because it did not provide any reasons as to why the parties felt that there was an absence of a likelihood of confusion nor did the agreement address any steps taken by the parties to avoid confusion in the marketplace.  The boards conclusion was that the agreement was mere "naked consent" and insufficient.

Another major mistake the applicant made was citing confidentiality as a reason why a more detailed copy of the agreement could not be submitted to the examiner after such detail was requested.  The TTAB would not go along with this.  One curiosity of the opinion, I thought, was that the TTAB said the applicant could have submitted a redacted copy of the full consent agreement to the examining attorney. The value of such a heavily redacted document, which might have provided little to no detail on the content requirements, seems questionable.

The take-away lessons from this case are:  (1)  follow the TMEP 1207.01(d)(viii) guidelines when working with a consent to register agreement.  Put in details that might demonstrate a lack of likelihood of confusion to the USPTO examining attorneys.  Also consider inserting clauses describing any agreements on usage or other restrictions with the registrant.  Lastly, redacted copies and confidentiality issues concerning these types of agreements may come back to bite an applicant later in the trademark prosecution process.  The agreement is a tool to show the USPTO why your mark should be registered.  Making relevant information un-viewable or un-available to the examiners could result in your agreement worthless.

*In re E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co., 476 F.2d 1357 (CCPA 1973)